Casey Anthony Joins TikTok—And The Internet Is Not Having It
Casey Anthony is back in the public eye, and social media is not happy about it. After keeping a low profile for years, she’s now on TikTok and Substack, presenting herself as a “legal advocate.” But instead of a warm welcome, she’s facing a massive backlash from users who haven’t forgotten her past.
A Quick Recap: Why Is Casey Anthony So Controversial?
For those who need a refresher, Casey Anthony became one of the most infamous figures in recent history after the tragic death of her 2-year-old daughter, Caylee Anthony, in 2008. The case captured national attention, with months of investigations and a highly publicized trial in 2011.
Although prosecutors argued that Casey was responsible for her daughter’s death, a jury acquitted her of murder, manslaughter, and child abuse charges. However, she was convicted of lying to law enforcement, a key part of why so many remain skeptical of her today.
Now, over a decade later, Casey Anthony has resurfaced—and she’s trying to rebrand herself.
Casey Anthony on TikTok: What Is She Doing?
Casey recently launched a TikTok account (@caseyanthony_substack) and a Substack newsletter, claiming she’s been working in the legal field since 2011 and now wants to use her voice to advocate for herself and others.
In her first video, she says:
“I am a legal advocate, I am a researcher, and I feel it’s necessary to start advocating for myself.”
She also expressed support for women’s rights, LGBTQ+ rights, and the legal community—which, understandably, many people are side-eyeing.
Alongside her TikTok debut, she’s launched a Substack newsletter, where she promises to share insights into the legal system and her personal experiences.
But instead of inspiring meaningful discussions, her new social media presence has sparked major outrage.
@caseyanthony_substack Raw, uncut, unfiltered. Join me on Substack, https://substack.com/@therealcaseyanthony It’s time we stand in the light together. #fyp
Social Media Reacts: “No One Asked For This”
It didn’t take long for TikTok, Reddit, and Twitter to erupt with disbelief and frustration.
One of the top comments under her video reads:
👉 “Casey Anthony being on TikTok is proof that this app has zero shame.”
Another user wrote:
👉 “This is beyond tone-deaf. We all know what happened, and NO ONE wants your legal advice.”
Over on Reddit, a thread about her TikTok went viral, with people saying she’s trying to profit off her infamy and calling her new venture “an insult to actual legal advocates.”
Even high-profile voices have chimed in.
Nancy Grace, a former prosecutor and longtime critic of Casey Anthony, slammed her TikTok move, calling it “a desperate money grab.”
Brad Conway, a lawyer who previously represented Casey’s parents, said:
“No one needs Casey Anthony’s advocacy. This is nothing but a self-serving attempt at relevance.”
Photo Credit: Peacock
Is This Just a Rebrand Attempt?
There’s no denying that Casey Anthony has remained a controversial figure in the years since her trial. But this sudden push to be seen as a “legal expert” has people questioning her real motives.
Is she genuinely interested in helping people? Or is this a calculated move to monetize her notoriety?
While she has the right to rebuild her life, many argue that launching a TikTok “advocacy” brand feels opportunistic—especially when there are so many qualified legal professionals who actually fight for justice.
Final Thoughts
Casey Anthony’s return to the spotlight is stirring up a lot of emotions—and very few of them are positive.
Her attempt to become a TikTok legal advocate has been met with massive backlash, and unless she acknowledges why people are so upset, this PR move is likely to backfire.
One thing’s for sure—the internet doesn’t forget.
